India’s Social Media Puzzle: Why Homegrown Platforms Still Can’t Break Through

India has built one of the strongest digital foundations in the world with UPI, large e-commerce platforms and successful ride-hailing companies. Yet, the country continues to fall behind when it comes to creating homegrown social media platforms that can grow, survive and compete globally. Many earlier ventures, including Hike and Koo, saw early excitement but failed to sustain growth due to weak scale, funding gaps, slow innovation and a heavy dependence on copying features already available on global apps. Even with the rising push for digital self-reliance, building a strong Indian social platform remains a long and complicated task.

A Massive User Base but Limited Local Success

India is the world’s second-largest social media market with around 491 million active users out of the global 5.5 billion. The growth of affordable smartphones, low data rates and the expansion of 4G and 5G networks have brought millions online.

Indian users spend about 2 hours and 26 minutes on social platforms every day, higher than users in countries like the US, UK and China. With the country’s internet population nearing one billion, there is still a huge untapped audience for social media.

Despite this, Indian apps have not been able to capture even a small portion of this fast-growing base.

The Strong Pull of Established Global Platforms

Social media works on a network effect where every new user adds value for others. This creates a strong advantage for established global players like Instagram, YouTube and X. Most Indian users, creators and advertisers are already active on these platforms, leaving little incentive to shift to a new Indian app.

Users prefer platforms where their friends and favourite creators already exist, making it almost impossible for local apps to attract a large group at once. Without high engagement and strong communities, advertisers stay away, leading to a slow collapse in user activity.

Struggles with Innovation and User Retention

Some Indian platforms gained early traction due to government support and rising interest in self-reliant products. Koo once had around 10 million monthly active users. Zoho’s Arattai also saw a major spike in downloads, jumping from less than 10,000 to over 7 million in a few months.

But gaining downloads is not the same as retaining daily users. Global apps constantly roll out new features and better user experiences. WhatsApp, for example, keeps introducing updates even without strong competition.

Indian platforms, on the other hand, have struggled to innovate consistently. Most new features arrive late, and many apps end up imitating global platforms rather than offering something fresh. Without regular improvements and community-building, user interest quickly drops.

The Funding and Monetisation Roadblock

A social media platform needs years of investment before it can start earning through ads or subscriptions. Technology upgrades, creator rewards, user-acquisition campaigns and server maintenance require deep pockets.

Most Indian start-ups cannot keep up with these costs due to slow or inconsistent funding. After the post-pandemic boom, investor interest in this sector has dipped sharply.

The Indian digital advertising market also remains weak for local players, with Meta and Google capturing a majority of ad spend. This makes it harder for new entrants to build strong revenue models.

Koo’s shutdown is a clear example, even after raising nearly $70 million across seven rounds. Without monetisation and new investors, growth becomes impossible.

The Vernacular Opportunity and Its Limits

Local-language content offers a major opportunity for Indian platforms, with 98% of internet users accessing content in regional languages by 2024. Even urban users show a strong preference for vernacular content.

Creating platforms that support local languages can bring in millions of new users and also attract advertisers interested in regional markets.

However, building separate apps for different languages can divide the audience. The smarter strategy is to create vernacular-friendly platforms with AI translation, better discovery tools and mixed-language feeds that appeal to a wider group.

To scale nationwide, these platforms need a simple interface, smooth performance on affordable smartphones and strong revenue models that include advertising, digital payments and business tools for small companies.

The Road Ahead for Indian Social Platforms

For India to build a successful homegrown social platform, the focus must shift to deep innovation, stronger funding support, powerful creator ecosystems and truly seamless multilingual experiences.

With the government’s growing push for digital independence and India’s expanding online population, the opportunity is huge. But success will come only when these platforms offer something unique, reliable and engaging enough to pull users away from global giants.

Keep reading The Reelstars for more such insightful pieces.